MMF: I note that in my conversation with Andrew Gould , he also pointed to the automotive industry analogy. This plays into OFS financials, correct?
BDD: Yes, over cycles and/or statistically relevant periods of years, critical financial measurements of intrinsic performance such as free cash flow (FCF) or return on capital employed (ROCE) have been typically coming short with the exception of a handful of the historical largest players such as Schlumberger and/or the occasional small specialist technology player. Few in the industry have been able to generate FCF and ROCE in excess of cost of capital on a consistent basis beyond a year or two and not through cycles. This has led to a perception of an uneconomic industry and reflected gradually in lower availability of capital and/or higher cost of capital.
This has been made worse by a contextual shift in strategic views by the financial markets and in turn within the OFS community on the industry’s long term prognosis and therefore intrinsic value.
MMF: The shifting views on the future of oil and the oil industry?
BDD: Coming out of the 1980s and 1990s, there was a strong belief in peak oil supply, and that the passing of time in of itself would imply an increasing demand for OFS and therefore a greater inherent value. The industry’s future value was structurally on an uptrend. In other words aside from any other considerations, time was on our, as in OFS’, side. The industry felt implicitly and for some good reason at the time that ever-increasing “plumbing” requirements to prevent increasing demand from potentially overwhelming supply and even more so a pending peak supply, would support a rising valuation as in higher multiples. We were an industry in increasing importance to manage away a structural limit on supply which would have been a strategic threat to the world economy. Something like that.
MMF: But we have had repeated cycles of supply and demand balances and rising and falling oil prices.
BDD: True, but that was perceived as inevitable cyclicality on our way to an improved secular growth trend to higher needs for OFS as a byproduct of peak supply. We saw in fact a rising trend in plumbing demand underlying short term cycles. There was an implicit belief in peak supply and the expectation was that OFS would deliver along the way to this peak supply an increasing “final value” for investors and shareholders. It wasn’t said explicitly or even articulated with economic or financial jargon. But it was something almost tangible in the OFS soul and de facto optimism as to our long term future.
MMF: I guess that even when I was working most closely on OFS I did not see as strong a conviction as you describe, although certainly, plenty of people were convinced.
BDD: Yes, implicitly or explicitly convinced. Then things shifted profoundly. One was the increasingly vocal dissatisfaction with stewardship of capital by the financial markets primarily addressed to two segments of the oil industry: U.S. independents and OFS. Financial markets were tired of waiting for future improvements in performance even if tied to this notion of increasing intensity of use of OFS to stave off peak supply.
The second factor was the immensely powerful escalation of climate change as a societal and political priority. The “peak supply” thesis had converted to one of “peak demand”. This changes everything long term and further highlights the need for immediate as in now financial returns commensurate with capital expectations. There is no secular or structural improvements in business conditions to support patience on financial performance. It’s quite the opposite. The future is now.
MMF: Where does this leave things for OFS?
BDD: There is only one way to go – there has to be better cash, better returns on capital (ROC) through cycles and effective now. Easy enough of a statement. The question is how? Consolidation is not as often the answer as financial analysts like to say. Barriers to entry are quite low in much of the OFS industry particularly in the North American market. Competitors and destructive competitive intensity grow back like weeds.
Nor is bankruptcy, for that matter a reliable or structural answer. Chapter 11 is often the enemy of progress insofar as it keeps alive an untenable level of competitive pressures with less existential pressures to generate cash insofar as the balance sheet isn’t pressing for cash generation anymore or as much.
The only structural solution in my mind is to revolutionize cost structures, once and for all and rationalize the industry through ruthless cost performance.
MMF: How, exactly? Technology? Something else?
BDD: Technology is always desirable and necessary of a pursuit and a powerful competitive force but often not the only or sufficient answer. Andrew [Gould] is correct about that. Look at pressure pumping – former management of larger players with ample private equity backing created startups that have no technological ability to differentiate themselves from the others and almost doomed to deliver poor returns through cycles. How can that ever work? And it’s not the only example I could provide. The OFS industry needs to spawn companies with a dramatically lower cost structure and I mean for lack of a better term, ruthlessly cheap but yet with highly competitive technology and quality of delivery. These companies will eliminate the excessive competitive pressures the only sustainable way it can be done: by displacing them systematically in the market place yet cover their cash cost of capital along the way. It can be done. Other industries have [done it]. In economic jargon, this new breed of OFS players will permanently lower the industry’s long term marginal cost curve which incidentally in turn will allow the oil industry to live more easily with lower pricing than the often referenced $60 to $70 or even $50 to $60 desirable range.
MMF: But you raised the issue of climate politics and the great fear is that oil industry businesses will not be worth anything in the future.
BDD: Climate politics is reality. Without going into a debate on its legitimacy or the effect of the current pandemic on public finances making transition financing harder etc., the simple fact is the lower the price of oil and gas, the harder it will be for the transition to take place and the longer the operating runway for our industry. It is more complex and nuanced than I just expressed here but the fundamental underlying logic applies. We need a new breed of OFS companies and fewer ones, not just Chapter 11 one time deleveraging. We are temporarily removing the symptom, we are not changing the root cause.
MMF: Well, to me, that kind of profound restructuring means new entrepreneurs, new ways of contracting, data science – real data science for management and logistics. Maybe even private ownership? Getting out of the public markets?
BDD: All of that if it helps. The key is structural cost revolution by a few determined players and survival of the fittest. It can be done. The OFS industry will be transformed. For Source info, Click Here!
CNC MACHINES
EPIC PROJECTS
HP CLEANING OF EX CHANGERS
PWHT & NDT SERVICES
1502 IRON
2d / 3d / 4d / Marine Siesmic Acquisition Processing
6G ARC – PIPE WELDING (SMAW)
A LEADING COMPANY IN OIL & GAS
Active Carbon Supply & Services
Actuator Onsite Services
ADAPTORS
Agitators
Air Balancing / Testing / Commissioning
ALL MECHANICAL WORKS IN DISTRICT COOLING PLANT PROJECTS
ANCILLARY EQUIPMENT
ANNUAL MAINTENANCE
BARRIERS
Bearings
Belts
BIN & INDUSTRIAL EQUIPMENTS
BOLT TENSIONING / TORQUING SERVICES
BOLT TORQUING
BOLTING SOLUTIONS
Bops
BUILDING SERVICES
BUILDING SERVICES PIPING FOR CHILLED WATER AND FIRE FIGHTING
Bulk Lpg
BUNDLE PULLING SERVICES
BUSBAR
BUSHES
CABLE JOINTING
CABLE TESTING
CALIBRATION SERVICES
CASE WEAR RINGS
CASING CUTTING
CASING MILLING
CASING PATCHES
CASING PULLING
CASING RECOVERY
CAST RESIGN DRY TYPE TRANSFORMERS
CATALYST HANDLING SERVICES
Catering & Support Services
Catering & Support Services For Labour Camps / Remote Sites / Institutional & Industrial Units / Oil & Gas Field / Gas Industries
CATHODIC PROTECTION
CEMENT INTEGRITY
CENTRAL BATTERIES
CERTIFICATION & TRAINING / GEOTECHNICAL ENGINEERING
CERTIFICATION & TRAINING / SCAFFOLDING INSPECTION
Certification / Classification / Inspection Services
Certified E & I Service Personnel For Ex - Installation
CHEMICAL CLEANING & DECONTAMINATION PROCESS PIPE & VESSEL CLEANING
Chemical Cleaning In Place
CHEMICAL CLEANING SERVICES
COLLAPSE PRESSURE
COLMONOY CASING WEAR RINGS
COLMONOY IMPELLER WEAR RINGS
COMMISSIONING
Complete Evaluation Package
Completions
COMPRESSED AIR SYSTEMS
CONSTRUCTION & DIVING EQUIPMENT
CONSTRUCTION & PROJECT MANAGEMENT
Consultancy Services
CONSULTANTS FOR PRODUCED WATER HANDLING & INJECTION
Consultants For Produced Water Handling / Injection
CONTROL SYSTEMS FOR VARIOUS APPLICATION
CORROSION LOGGING
Corrosion Management & Specialist Environmental Consultancy
Corrosion Related Studies
CORROSIVE WELL INSTALLATIONS
Couplings
CRADLE
CRIMPING FACILITY & SERVICE OF HOSES
CROSSOVERS
DB
DECOKING / DESCALING SERVICES
DESIGN
DESIGN & FABRICATION OF OFFSHORE BASKETS
DIAGNOSTICS
DISC THRUSTS
Distribution Systems
DIVING & CONSTRUCTION ACTIVITIES
Diving Contractors
DOWN HOLE TOOLS
DOWN HOLE TOOLS & HANDLING EQUIPMENT
Downhole Calipers
Downhole Pressure Gauges
Downhole Sampling
Downhole Wireline Tools
DOWNSTREAM
DRILL PIPE
Drill Stem Subs
Drill Through Equipment
DRILLING
DRILLING LOSSES
DRILLING RENTAL EQUIPMENT
Drilling Rig Contractors
DRY ICE BLASTING SERVICES
Dry Ice Cleaning / Bolt Tensioning / Torquing / Flange Facing / Pipe Cutting / In Situ Machining
Dst
DUAL STRING MILLING
Eddy Current Inspection Services For Heat Exchangers
ELECTRICAL ROTATING MACHINERIES
EMERGENCY PIPELINE REPAIR CLAMP
ENERGY METER
ENGINEERING / CONSULTANCY SERVICES
ENGINEERING SERVICES
Epc Construction Contractors
EQUIPMENT ERECTION
EQUIPMENT HIRE
ESEAL
ESET
Etc
ETC FOR BUILDING GLASS CLEANING SYSTEMS
Ex - Inspection & Maintenance Of Onshore & Offshore Electric / Instruments
EXPANDABLE LINERS
FABRICATION & MACHINE SHOPS
FABRICATION OF HOOPERS
FABRICATION OF OFFSHORE CONTAINERS & BASKETS
FABRICATION OF PIPING STEEL SPOOLS
FABRICATION OF STORAGE TANKS
FEEDER PILLAR
Ff Bus Systems
FIELD SERVICES & ONSITE SUPPORT
Filters
FINFAN AND BOILERS
Fireproofing / Anti - Corrosion Coating / Sludge Removal Contractors
FLANGE TESTING
Flanges
Flare Tip Replacement & Jetty Services
FLOW CONTROL
FLUID FLOW
FLUX CORED ARC WELDING (FCAW)
Foam Treatment Of Air Cooled Heat Exchangers
Food Supply To Offshore Vessels
Fuel Injection Workshop
Fuel Storage
FULLY INTEGRATED SERVICES
GAS & PETROCHEMICAL INDUSTRIES
GAS TUNGESTEN ARC WELDING (GTAW)
General Contracting Services
Geophysical Surveys
GLOBAL CARE SOFTWARE
GRINDING MACHINES
HANDRAIL & CARBON STEEL PIPING WORKS
Hard Banding Of Drill Pipes
HEAT EXCHANGER RE-TUBING
High Quality Risk / Safety / Reliability Management Services
Hose Assembly Workshop
Hoses
HOT TAPPING
HOUSING COVERS
Hydraulic Hoses
HYDRO TESTING
IMPELLER NUTS
IMPELLER WEAR RINGS
In Line Valve Sealant Services
IN SITU MACHINING SOLUTIONS
INDUCER NUTS
Industrial Chemical Cleaning
Industrial Safety Training
INDUSTRIAL TANK CLEANING
INDUSTRIAL VACUUMING SERVICES
INDUSTRIAL WASTE MANAGEMENT SERVICES